BSV Forum - General - The Bloodshedpub

Secondary character death warnings - necessary spoilers?

Feb 03 2008 09:10 pm   #1NautiBitz
This is probably a question best asked of the mods first, since I'm not sure of the specific rules here; but I extend it to everyone:

Let's say, hypothetically speaking of course, an author -- not me; a uh, friend... ;) -- kills off a key character who isn't Spike or Buffy, and feels that putting up a warning could possibly spoil the ending. Do readers need this warning? Or is it okay to leave it as a surprise?

(And mods, if authors must put in character death warnings no matter who it is, then that answers my question, too.)
~ * ~ * ~ * ~
Start With A Slap by Sirena Wise
Book One of the SLAP/BANG duet
Adapted from the NautiBitz fanfic "Crave"
Available now on Amazon & Kindle Unlimited
sirenawise.com
Feb 03 2008 09:49 pm   #2Always_jbj
No, you don't HAVE to put in a death warning for any of the characters, and I personally never do--I hate spoilers!
Aim from the heart
Some will love and some will curse you, baby
You can go to war
But only if you have to 


Fanfic ~*~ Artwork ~*~ Live Journal
Feb 03 2008 10:03 pm   #3slaymesoftly
No, you don't have to. We are of the opinion that readers should be prepared for any eventuality. :)
I am not a minion of Evil...
I am upper management.
Feb 03 2008 10:07 pm   #4Diabola

Nope, character death is not something you have to warn about - rules wise. Esp if it isn't Buffy or Spike.

-- That was me being a mod, as for personal opinion, I prefer to be warned about a character death if it is going to have a strong emotional impact on me. Especially if it happens toward the end of the story and whatever grief one may experience won't be resolved by the end of the fic. (Yes, I know, grieving for a fictional character, makes me sound a bit daft, can't think of a better word though.) If it happens early on, or with enough stuff coming afterward that the impact is dampened by the time the story is finished, I don't mind so much. It's up to the author whether they want to warn about CD though, I know quite a few people consider it a spoiler and prefer not to use it.

Ugh, sorry if this is slightly incoherent. Am talking to my mom on YM while writing this, and switching languages like this is not something I'm good at.

ETA: Seeing Always_jbj's comment, I should probably add that I'm a huge spoiler whore; I frequently read the endings of books or fics before the rest. As far as I can tell, that's a rather unusual mindset, so you should probably mostly ignore my opinion. ;-)

"The difference between genius and stupidity is that genius has limits." - Albert Einstein
Feb 03 2008 10:40 pm   #5NautiBitz
Oh, thanks, this is very good to know! ....for my friend.

;D

(Personally, as a reader, I only need to know if Spike or Buffy is going to die. Permanently, that is -- if they're eventually resurrected, there's no need for warning. Like you, Dia, I like to be warned in advance that I'll be experiencing a total emotional meltdown. But other characters, I can usually handle.)
~ * ~ * ~ * ~
Start With A Slap by Sirena Wise
Book One of the SLAP/BANG duet
Adapted from the NautiBitz fanfic "Crave"
Available now on Amazon & Kindle Unlimited
sirenawise.com