BSV Forum - General - The Bloodshedpub

Essay on fanfiction

Nov 05 2009 04:39 am   #1lovesbitch91
So I'm writing my final essay for my English class on the value of fanfiction. It's mostly about how fanfiction deserves the same respect as original fiction, as many consider it a viable form of literature. Anyways, it is supposed to be a research paper, and I'm in desperate need of citable sources. And links or suggestions? They would be greatly appreciated. I know we're not technically supposed to use wikipedia, but it may be a last resort if I can't find any good sites to help me out. So yeah, thanks for any help you guys! It's greatly appreciated. :-)

Nov 05 2009 07:08 am   #2Sensei
If you have an lj acct. (and maybe if you don't cause I don't really understand these things!) you should contact anaross.  She is an English college professor who has written some of the most moving Spuffy fanfic I've ever read. You can't get a more prestigious source than that!  Ask her if she'll email you a copy of a professional presentation on fanfic that she gave not too long ago.  (A few months back on her lj site she was offering to send a copy to anyone who asked.)  Ask if you can cite it in your paper--and ask her if she has other "professional" comments for you that you can use as a reference in your paper.  There are a lot of other fanfic writers and authors who have written essays on fanfiction; if I come across any of the old ones I've read, I'll send them your way.  Anyone else have suggestions for her?

Nov 05 2009 04:02 pm   #3lovesbitch91
Okay, So I've just finished e-mailing both anaross and Herself, as I know Herself recently gave a presentation on fanfiction as well. Right now, the writing of the essay is going great - it's the research and citing of sources that has me at a loss... So yeah, any other suggestions would be beyond helpful. :-)

Nov 05 2009 05:02 pm   #4nmcil
you have  the list of professional writers who have also taken the same source material of The Whedonverse into the successful publishing business.  Same with what happened in the Jane Austen books - You should contact The Republic of Pemberley site for input from their writers and readers - a great FF and Jane Austen resource site.
” Recent evolutionary models have demonstrated what politicians have long known: the best way to get people to collaborate and to think like a group is to identify an enemy and charge that “they” threaten “us.”

Michael Tomasello is co-director of the Max Planck Institute for Evolutionary Anthropology.
Nov 05 2009 11:04 pm   #5slaymesoftly
Anaross should be an excellent source - both of primary materials, and as someone who can point you at more sources.  There are many, many meta posts on LJ, but I don't know how you'd find them.  You might check the tags for Rahirah (Barb C) and also see if Nan Dibble's account is still up. Not sure where else you could look for essays on fanfic.  You could certainly try a search engine like google and see what turns up.
I am not a minion of Evil...
I am upper management.
Nov 06 2009 07:32 am   #6nmcil
Those folks over at Tea At The Ford also would be an excellent source -
” Recent evolutionary models have demonstrated what politicians have long known: the best way to get people to collaborate and to think like a group is to identify an enemy and charge that “they” threaten “us.”

Michael Tomasello is co-director of the Max Planck Institute for Evolutionary Anthropology.
Nov 06 2009 12:46 pm   #7Mesh 
What nmcil and Slayme said. Those should really help! Fantastic sources!. But just FYI if ever you're in a hurry to do homework, go to several different pages and copy-past what you think is most interesting.

Skim through it and make sure it has some kind of literal synchronicity and flows nicely together. Delete words you know you wouldn't use and replace them with something else--et voila! Instant homework.

In college, the way I was supposed to do home work wasn't ALLOWED to be too original. When I was given the free will to write about whatever subject I wanted, I was given a bad grade because my teachers were biased. So then I learned--I just had to keep my homework simple and stupid... Like my professors.

It may not be the case for you or your teachers. They could be nice (had a few of those) but in my experience--you just gotta give them what THEY want. It's sad... But true.
Nov 06 2009 04:03 pm   #8Spikez_tart
Mesh - laughing at you!  Sad but true.

lovesbitch - Here are a couple of BSV forums.  First one was started by Zoegrace who has gone on to be published (woohoo!) and second is one about a fanfiction survey that someone did a couple of years ago.  She finished and posted the survey, you might still be able to find it.

http://216.177.134.59/forum.php?go=read&no=103



http://216.177.134.59/forum.php?go=read&no=1453

If we want her to be exactly she'll never be exactly I know the only really real Buffy is really Buffy and she's gone' who?
Nov 06 2009 08:55 pm   #9Sensei
I followed Mesh's link to the poll.  http://www.zoomerang.com/Shared/SharedResultsSurveyResultsPage.aspx?ID=L22T53L4M5GL It might be very useful for you--as well as interesting to all of us.  It was not a random, scientific poll, but the answers are fascinating:  the majority of readers are single, younger, prefer reading to watching TV as a leisure activity (while we obviously watch TV to get into a fandom, fanfic folks are big readers whose first contact with public libraries happened under age 12, so I assume we sre predispositioned to reading fanfic by our very natures.

Nov 07 2009 12:22 am   #10lovesbitch91
Thanks to everyone who's helped out so far. I've decided to use several quotes from members than I found in the first forum link Spikez_tart gave me, and I'm in the process of reading through the comments from the pool on zoomerang.com. I f you guys have any opinions on why you think fanfiction desevers the same respect, and is just as good, as original fiction, I'd love to hear them. :-)

Nov 07 2009 04:37 am   #11slaymesoftly
Um, Mesh? That sounds kissing close to plagiarism. I don't think it would fly in a lot of colleges.  It's usually pretty easy to spot copy/pasted stuff - the difference in writing styles for one thing.
I am not a minion of Evil...
I am upper management.
Nov 07 2009 02:04 pm   #12Mesh 
*quote* Um, Mesh? That sounds kissing close to plagiarism. I don't think it would fly in a lot of colleges.  It's usually pretty easy to spot copy/pasted stuff - the difference in writing styles for one thing.

I was wondering if someone was gonna comment on that. Hehe! You're sharp :D
I look for articles in English and translate them ;)
It more or less is plagiarism. Doesn't mean I don't know what I'm writing about. But my opinions are too broad, so in the end I feel like I'm wasting my time if I work too hard on something my professors are just gonna shoot down anyway.

An example (so you know I'm not that delusional):
For my practice exam I chose a subject based on the age/history of the world and Solar System. I've always been interested in that subject so it's what I wrote about.
I mentioned that the way they know the world is 4.billion years old (or so) is by studying old rocks. I had stated the fact that it doesn't prove anything because natural disasters and meteors could have wiped away any evidence that wold prove otherwise.

My professor didn't like that and gave me a low grade. After that I decided to just gather information that would make him (and the rest of them) happy because I had no say in the matter.
Nov 08 2009 03:03 am   #13Spikez_tart
LB - Here's what I think is good about fanfiction.  

For the writer, you get to practice your writing and get a lot more feedback than you might otherwise.  You get to try out things that you might not ever be able to get published.  You get to build up an audience.  You don't have to put up with your friends and family asking you when you're going to get published because you already are if you are posting.  You get to meet and chat with a lot of other writers, which you might not otherwise be able to do. Even if you never plan to go on and publish your own stories, learning to write gives you a much deeper appreciation of the published fiction you read.  You also get to explore the work of the writers of the original work in a more detailed way and get more interesting insights into what they were doing. 

For the reader, you get to read a lot of really well written stories about characters that you already know and love.  You also get to read some not so well written stuff, too, but that helps sharpen your understanding of what's good and what's not so good.  You get to comment on the writing if you feel like it.  You can volunteer to help writers by editing their work. 

The only downside I see to writing fanfic is that if you only use the characters in the show, you miss the opportunity to work on developing your own characters.  I usually try to include a new character in my pieces, partly for that reason. 

Let us know how your homework goes.  :)
If we want her to be exactly she'll never be exactly I know the only really real Buffy is really Buffy and she's gone' who?
Nov 09 2009 04:52 am   #14nmcil

Developing your creative skills in FF with new characters is such an important element - I don't understand why FF writers don't create their own characters more.  I love having new non Sunnydale characters in works, it is such an obvious way to work both with the characters you love and making developing your own fictional people. 

The thing that I love about FF and the INTERNET is what is has done for the creative lives of thousands of people.  People who love writing but have no outlets for their works can still keep up with that love.  Without the INTERNET and how it allows people to connect with others  who share a love and enthusiasm for a particular field, many of the FF would eventually give up writing or would never have started at all. 

The question of having respect for FF by the public at large or from the professional writers, while it might be important to some, I think that the creativity FF brings into the lives of the writers is perhaps even more important.  

Being able to live a creative life online has made a profound change for people, not just writers, but visual artist, musician, historians - and the list just goes on and on.  This connection online with people and your creative life is an immense change.   
 

” Recent evolutionary models have demonstrated what politicians have long known: the best way to get people to collaborate and to think like a group is to identify an enemy and charge that “they” threaten “us.”

Michael Tomasello is co-director of the Max Planck Institute for Evolutionary Anthropology.
Nov 10 2009 08:57 pm   #15Messiah
Couldn't have said it better myself, nmcil :)
The internet is good for soo much more aswell! So many doors have opened for people all over the world who otherwise would not have had the chance to learn and experience certain things ^_^

- If you want to win a war, you must serve no master but your own ambition..

-The greatest pleasure in life is doing what people say you cannot do.

- A religious war is like children fighting over who has the strongest imaginary friend.


Nov 11 2009 12:04 am   #16mesgh 
off topic, I know (it seems silly to make a board about this)
But what happened to the fic All My Family?? I love that story...but it's gone!! Did the author leave? oh no!! I wanted to know what happens ;(((((

Nov 11 2009 08:12 pm   #17Cordykitten
But what happened to the fic All My Family?? I love that story...but it's gone!! Did the author leave?

Was Spikeschilde author you are talking about? The story I know with this title is by Spikeschilde and you can find it here:
http://www.bloodshedverse.com/stories.php?go=chapters&no=1896
Sadly the story is on hold see  spikeschilde-89.livejournal.com/40463.html
Was that the story you're looking for?
Nov 12 2009 06:47 pm   #18Mesh 
Oh, yes! That's it.
It was spikeschilde! Sorry about the mix up. It's so sad she doesn't have time anymore. I really love that story. It makes me sad to hear -_-

Thanks for your help :)
Nov 13 2009 04:44 am   #19Sensei
11/12/2009 09:41 pm   #19
Although I'm a reader, not a fanfic writer, as a teacher I have an observation regarding a strength of fanfic over regular writing.  Some people write for themselves; others write for an audience.  If you are the type whose motivation is to share with others, with fanfiction there is already a built in audience.  You know there will be people out there eager to read your work.  Writing regular fiction is a solitary occupation, but fanfiction and the web give a writers a support group, encouragement, and even feedback to help strengthen their writing (especially if the writer posts it as each chapter is completed at a site like this where readers can leave comments immediately).  And, in general, I think that fanfic communities are especially friendly and supportive.  Writers don't see one another as competition; they have a unique positive bond that is nurturing and can't be found anywhere else.

So to those of you who write---am I correct in my assumptions?

Nov 13 2009 10:53 pm   #20Spikez_tart
You are definitely right Dangerous. 
If we want her to be exactly she'll never be exactly I know the only really real Buffy is really Buffy and she's gone' who?
Nov 14 2009 02:14 am   #21slaymesoftly
I'd say that you're pretty much on target, Sensei. Although, there are also writers in the RW who support each other and provide feedback and community.  Maybe more so now than there used to be? So many writers now seem to have come from the fanfiction community, I think they carry that sense of community with them if/when they move into the harsher world of publishing.
I am not a minion of Evil...
I am upper management.