The Circle Unbroken by DizzyB

Just Me
12/13/2006 07:50 am
Ch 6 - Revelations         
I love this story! Really and truly I do!

Deb
10/30/2006 02:12 am
Ch 6 - Revelations         
Wonderful fun. Hope that this fic continues to inspire you.
Inspire - yes. Free up my schedule to write more - still working on that one! Thanks for reviewing. Working on the next chapter now. :)

time of change
10/28/2006 04:04 pm
Ch 6 - Revelations         
I'm hooked. I had my doubts before taking a look at this story, but this crossover works for me. I like the plottiness and the characterizations and the OCs are very good.
I totally get that. There have been several stories that just didn't appeal to me based on the description, title, etc. Then I read a chapter or two and was totally hooked myself. Thanks for being so honest. I like that you were willing to give me a chance and I like what you have to say. Hope I can keep up the quality. :P

sirc
10/27/2006 03:29 pm
Ch 6 - Revelations         
Loved it :D
Love you, you good reviewer, you! :)

SpaceLord
10/26/2006 07:08 pm
Ch 6 - Revelations         
Love the story great to see an update to it. Love the fact that it takes place in LOTR but you don't rush into the whole ring thing. I hope u have them cross path but on some level keep Spikes and the Scoobies adventure somewhat separate
You know, that's actually one of the plot points I'm trying to determine at the moment. I know where a few Scoobies have to end up for storyline purposes, but there are a couple that I just don't know what to do with yet. And I've got a few more chapters to decide all that, but it just hasn't come to me yet. It will, a story always goes where it's supposed to go...it's just that sometimes that direction can suprise even the author. Thanks for reviewing! :)

10/26/2006 07:05 pm
Ch 6 - Revelations         
like the way you stated each persons thoughts on the matter so clearly...if i would make one suggestion on this very well done fic, it would be to break the paragraphs up at bit...a huge paragraph can be a bit daunting for some readers (namely me :P) but other than that it's wonderful...and i love xander's little epiphany, especially :)
I do tend to be a bit wordy at times. Actually, I swear my whole life is composed of rambling run-ons with very little breathing space. Whew! I appreciate the input and I'll keep that in mind when I forget to breathe! :)

Seriously thought, thanks for taking the time to review and for the kind words. Glad you're liking Xander. More soon. :)

Dihcar
10/26/2006 12:03 pm
Ch 6 - Revelations         
Very nice indeed, the people that tell the story are the ones that call his deceased wife, his true love. I do think that Spike loved her very much, but he doesn't just call anyone his true love. Being deceived once and thinking that it was Dru for a 100y, and with Buffy they really didn't get that far enough.
I like your Spike more then season5 Spike who was quite pathetic imo. Yours is a true hero, deciding to fight on his own.

Seeya
I've always liked the idea of Spike deciding to be his own man and doing it for the right reasons. As far as true love goes, I'm not going to weigh in just yet - mostly because I'll probably give it all away if I do. :P Wait till you hear from Spike or some of his friends who were around back then, and then I'd be very interested to hear what you think on the subject. Thanks for taking the time to review and for the gracious comments. :)

kim
10/26/2006 10:41 am
Ch 6 - Revelations         
Revelations, indeed.
I like that - a nice succinct reply. As you can see, I'm not so good with the short stuff myself. My friends laugh at me because even the simplest of text messages ends up using up the limit of allowed characters when I'm writing it! :P

Angi
10/26/2006 10:18 am
Ch 6 - Revelations         
So, let me get this straight, Spike moved on a few years after jumping into the portal, giving up on ever returning, and after losing his wife he didn´t move on for fifty years? Well, he must´ve loved Buffy bunches, right?
Aside from that, I know, this is going to be a long tale and you have lots of plans with this. And I know I will follow every word and wait anxiously for every chapter, because I am already hooked on your tale and because I like that you take your time and you are developing this slowly.
But as of yet, this Spike is a stranger to me, and that he moved on from Buffy quite easily and his elven wife was his one true love he never moved on from doesn´t sit well with me at all, and despite knowing, for once, Spike was loved, I don´t know how you are going to work this out for them. I believe that you can love more than once in your life, but that there is only one true love. So if Spike had that already, it is like Buffy is only second best, and that saddens me, because it´s the worst feeling of all to be the solace price or weak substitute.
But I trust you to come up with something amazing, this story so far proves that you have great ideas. Guess I have to wait what you have up your sleeve.... Just don´t wait too long to have Spike and Buffy talking a few things out, please. Or just ignore me and do what you want, I´ll gobble your words up anyway :-))
Wow. This may be the longest review yet! Awesome. I know a lot of people have their doubts about the 'true love' bit. Trust me - I've heard from them!

I'm going to ask that you be patient with where I'm going on that track and let it develop. I think it will be satisfying for everyone...or so I hope anyway.

But let me ask you this one question on that topic: What represents true love to you? Is it how you feel about soemone else, how they feel about you, a grand gesture of sacrifice, a feeling of safety, stormy passion? I would venture that true love means different things to each person, and with that in mind, hope you are satisfied with how this pans out.

As for Spike being a stranger... I'm thrilled that you feel that way! He should be a stranger to everyone after 60 years. Bravo!

Thanks for the confidence and I'll try to get the rest out soon so you have more to chew on. :)

kim
10/26/2006 09:53 am
Ch 6 - Revelations         
So, do they think he's of Numenorean blood, to be long-lived and not aging? Aragorn was well over 200 when he laid down his life...
Have you read The Silmarillion as many times, too?
Hmm. Interesting theory that bears consideration. Strider is coming within the next two chapters - promise!

Totally love all the Tolkien books. He was such a genius. Have been re-reading them annually since I was twelve and that was...let's see...longer back than I realized. Scary. :P

sirc
10/27/2006 03:11 pm
Ch 5 - Learning Curves         
Ooh!... Intresting development! :D
Read on and let me know what you think. :)

valdt
10/27/2006 03:47 am
Ch 5 - Learning Curves         
excellent update, thank you. anya as practical as ever; xander growing up; tara channeling earthmother; dawn seeing a way to unite her best friend and her sister; and then there is red, as egocentric as ever. very enjoyable read.
Thanks. I'm still enjoying writing this one. Glad you like it. Some people really do come by change on their own...while others react in a healthy manner by considering ideas or events that challenge the way they think...while still others never change, because nothing is ever their fault. Willow always fell into that last category to me. She didn't like negative consequences, but always wanted to thing that she knew how to 'do it right this time.' :P

Stella
08/20/2006 05:26 am
Ch 5 - Learning Curves         
WOW! Amazing story. Great crossover idea. I hope you will update again soon because I can't wait to see the Scoobies meet Strider. :)
And that is coming soon - within the next 2 chapters! Thanks for the awesome review. Appreciate your continued patience as this story unravels. It's been on the backburner while I completed the next section of The Path Less Traveled which should be posted within a week. Once that's up, look for more updates here. Thanks again! :)

margaret
08/02/2006 12:38 am
Ch 5 - Learning Curves         
the plot thickens. loving this story. lovely to see spike as a hero
Thank you so much! I'm having fun writing this story. It's been on the backburner while I was working on the next section of The Path Less Traveled. It's almost done and will be up soon. As soon as I post that, I will be back on regular intervals for updates here. Thanks for being patient! :)

SpaceLord
08/01/2006 07:14 pm
Ch 5 - Learning Curves         
Oh Spike had a wife....sweet....hope this story is updated soon this just got way more interesting.
So sorry for the long delay in updates. I had to put my other WIPs on hold to finish the next section of The Path Less Traveled. You can expect to see that up within a week or so and then this should begin updating shortly thereafter. Thanks again for reviewing! :)

08/01/2006 06:15 pm
Ch 5 - Learning Curves         
Oooh! Clifhanger! This chapter was worth the wait, and if you explain a little bit more, I know the next chapter will be, too.
Thanks for the vote of confidence. I know you've already waited quite some time now, but I promise to start updating again soon. I'm almost finished the next section of The Path Less Traveled and once it's done, I'll be back on track here. Thanks for the kind review and for your continued patience! :)

dihcar
08/01/2006 12:03 pm
Ch 5 - Learning Curves         
I really do hope that he had a wife who he truly loved. Spike hasn't had someone truly love him unconditionly in all his life/unlife except his mother but that was a different kind of love. And Buffy has no right to be jealous, she still thinks that vile angel is her true love in canon.
I think you'll appreciate where this story is going next. Sorry for the long delay in posting. I've been hard at work on the next section of The Path Less Traveled and that takes so much time to write that everything else has to wait in the meantime. Hope to begin updating again shortly. Thanks again for reviewing! :)

Angi
08/01/2006 10:49 am
Ch 5 - Learning Curves         
Terrific chapter, at least until that last part. Now Spike´s true love was his elven wife? So Buffy is what? Noone, replacement, what? He forgot Buffy after diving into the portal? As fine as it is that he had someone, that true love part bothers me to no end.
Hopefully you won't be as bothered when you see how I lay all that out. Speaking of which, I realize you've been waiting quite some time to do just that! Sorry for the lengthy delay but all my spare time has been aimed at completing the next section of The Path Less Traveled which I plan to post within a week or so. After that I should be back on regular update intervals with this tale. Thanks again for your comments and for taking the time to review! :)

Tonia
08/01/2006 10:23 am
Ch 5 - Learning Curves         
Great update! Willow needs to get over herself and I love Anya's way of looking at things. I wonder what the story behind Spike's wife is. Update soon, please?
I am so sorry for the very long delay in updating. I have been completely focused on finishing the next section of The Path Less Traveled which is my most demanding WIP and this has been on the backburner. I hope to have another chapter soon. Thanks for the review and your continued patience! :)

vladt
08/01/2006 09:41 am
Ch 5 - Learning Curves         
amazing tale. anya true to character,figuring how to best fit in and profit. willow concerned more about the loss of power than anything else. and buffy is sure to be jealous of spike's dead wife. fantastic tale, thank you.
Amazing? Wow! Thank You! Seriously, I'm sorry it's been so long since I updated. I had to put everything else on hold so I could complete the next section of The Path Less Traveled which has been quite arduous. I hope to have that up within a week and promise to begin updating this tale again soon. Thanks for your patience and enthusiasm! :)

Pulchra
08/01/2006 09:36 am
Ch 5 - Learning Curves         
yeah Buff, what now? I love this! (allthough I have a suspicion that it isn't exactly as she says... maybe he's just mourning Buffy ;-) and that elven wife was just a dear friend? lolz... or Buffy is going to have a jealous fit and it turns out it's all true... or it's something different alltogether....) anyway I'm still loving this story and eagerly waiting for an update!
Thanks for the wonderful review. I'm having a lot of fun writing this one. Sorry for the delay in posting. I wanted to get the next installment of The Path Less Traveled done and I can't focus on any other stories when I work on it because it's so demanding. Hope to post that within the next week and then promise to explain some of what's going on here. Thanks for your patience! :P

08/01/2006 07:21 am
Ch 5 - Learning Curves         
wow spike married? really loving this fic
Thanks for taking the time to review. Glad you're enjoying it & I promise I haven't forgotten this story. Sorry it's been so long since the last update. I've been hard at work on the next section of The Path Less Traveled and had to put everything else on the backburner as it is the most demanding story I'm working currently. I plan to post that within the week and will begin updating this story again soon. :)

08/01/2006 05:41 am
Ch 5 - Learning Curves         
hmmm...i think the lack of magic will probably be good for willow...if i remember rightly "magic -- for lack of a better word" was a natural part of the elves' makeup, right? not something someone could really "learn" or get by the means such as willow did...hmmm....interesting thought :)
i like anya's thoughts, too...very realistic to her character...i love anya :)
and wow! spike had an elven wife?? can't wait to hear more about that one!
excellent update, pet...can't wait for more ;)
Thanks for the generous review. Sorry it's been so long since the last update. I've been hard at work on the next section of The Path Less Traveled and had to put everything else on the backburner as it is the most demanding story I'm working currently. I plan to post that within the week and will begin updating this story again soon. Thank you again for your detailed comments. I appreciate reviews SO MUCH! :)

sir c
10/27/2006 02:46 pm
Ch 4 - The Man of the Hour         
well done :D
Thank you! Still having fun with this one. More soon (fingers crossed)

kim
10/26/2006 10:31 am
Ch 4 - The Man of the Hour         
I'm taking it that Tolkien's books have somehow been missed by the Scoobies? There were LOTR mentions on the show once the movies were coming out...Anyway, nice filling in of the blanks around daily life and structure. As thorough as Tolkien was, he didn't have space to cover certain things, with having to focus on the Fellowship's perspective.
Yeah, that's true, but most of those comments were made in Season Seven when Andrew did so much to bring out Xander's inner (barely hidden) geek. Before then, not so much...or so we're assuming for the purposes of this story.

That could have been another interesting take on this idea though...they end up in Middle-Earth, knowing the story and not knowing what to say or do to prevent screwing up the ultimate victory. Hmmm.

Anyway, thanks for taking the time to comment on the details and I do appreciate all the feedback. Hope you enjoy this story. :)

07/21/2006 11:13 am
Ch 4 - The Man of the Hour         
I just got a chance to read this, and I think anticipation to the next chapter might be a little hard on me!
I know it's been a while since you wrote this, so I hope the anticipation wasn't too bad. Will try to get future chapters out quicker. Enjoy! :)

07/12/2006 02:57 am
Ch 4 - The Man of the Hour         
love the up date, love the tone of the opening chapters, love the tale. thanks for the read.
Love your reviews, vlad! :) Thanks!!

07/10/2006 02:43 pm
Ch 4 - The Man of the Hour         
i like the setting you've created here...very intriguing, whimsical sort of air to this story, and i like it a lot...can't wait for more :)
Really appreviate your feedback. Glad you like the story and glad it apparently has the air I was shooting for with this one. (Big grin from DizzyB.) Hope you continue to enjoy. :)

Pulchra
07/10/2006 12:55 pm
Ch 4 - The Man of the Hour         
Ok... if you keep doing this my praise is going to get old really fast! How many times can you call something brilliant before the praise will bore you do death? *gniffle* I really love this... and somehow... it fits... Spike in Middle Earth...
Don't you know that praise never gets old? Boy did that sound conceited of me, huh? :) Seriously, I really appreciate the reviews. Sorry it took so long to get the next chapter up, but will try to do better. Enjoy!

07/10/2006 07:39 am
Ch 4 - The Man of the Hour         
another great chapter. i am loving this more and more. i really like how everyone is getting along with spike and not just another kick the spike fic :)
Glad you like it so much. Thanks for the review. Next chapter is finally up - sorry for the delay. :)

07/10/2006 06:33 am
Ch 4 - The Man of the Hour         
Another great chapter! I can't wait for more! =)
Sorry it took me so long to get this chapter up. Life sucks when it gets in the way of the fun stuff. :P

sirc
10/27/2006 02:30 pm
Ch 3 - Catching Up         
Loved this :D
Really appreciate the multiple reviews. Not everyone takes time to do that and it means so much. Thanks again and keep reading! :)

kim
10/26/2006 10:21 am
Ch 3 - Catching Up         
Turning up right during Bilbo's battle had to be interesting, indeed. One thing - you'll want to capatalize "Dunedain", because it's a name and title. "Rangers" is also a title of a group, so that's another consideration.

I was skeptical about reading this at first, but it's pretty neat so far..
Good point with the capitalization. Hadn't realized I'd overlooked that. And thanks for the positive comments. Always appreciate constructive criticism as well as gracious reviews! :)

vladt
07/08/2006 08:55 pm
Ch 3 - Catching Up         
very good update, very good tale. love seeing spike with an adoring public. thanks for the fine read.
Appreciate your reviews, vladt, as always. More soon, I promise. :)

07/08/2006 08:04 pm
Ch 3 - Catching Up         
What a great start for this crossover. More story please.
I almost didn't post this story at all 'cause I didn't think anyone would be interested in a crossover with LoTR. I couldn't have been more wrong about that! The response has been great and I promise the next chaper will be posted tonight. Thanks for reviewing. :)

Pulchra
07/08/2006 06:04 pm
Ch 3 - Catching Up         
more! please more!? God this is brilliant! ;-) I loved the LotR movies.. (not the books... sorry) anyway I love how you've woven everything into one!
Keep calling my work brilliant and you'll be amazed how quickly I can update! Seriously, I really appreciate the kind and generous words. Next chapter is up now, and I'm working on the next three chapters already. Enjoy! :)

Lindy
07/08/2006 03:50 pm
Ch 3 - Catching Up         
Nice to see Spike appreciated for the good things he does. Thanks for another great chapter.
Luv ya Lindy. Appreciate the feedback. :)

Dihcar
07/08/2006 12:22 pm
Ch 3 - Catching Up         
Very nice, i love Spike's hero status.
And that he travelled with Gandalf after meeting up during the battle, where i'm sure he was a very valuable asset. Since he is one of the best warriors in the verse.

seeya
I'm glad you like it. In all my other stories, Spike has to earn the respect. And for once I wanted him to have already earned it by the time the Scoobies came on the scene. Hope you'll enjoy what comes next as much. :)

Tonia
07/08/2006 08:57 am
Ch 3 - Catching Up         
:::cheers::: I like hero Spike.
This story is so cool. =)
Why thank you very much. Glad you like it. More soon, I promise. :)

07/08/2006 07:35 am
Ch 3 - Catching Up         
great chapter.can't wait to see what happens when you add in the lotr cast.
Promise that's coming soon. Thanks for reviewing. Makes me happy and a happy author writes faster! :P

07/08/2006 06:06 am
Ch 3 - Catching Up         
I'm quickly growing to love this story! I like how you're tying everything in together, blending the worlds smoothly. Can't wait for more!
I'm trying so hard to blend them, so thank you so much for noticing that. And thanks for reviewing. Next chapter is up now. Enjoy! :)

07/08/2006 05:16 am
Ch 3 - Catching Up         
wow...okay, i am totally getting lost in this world you've created..or not so much created -- in all fairness to Whedon and Tolkien :P lol -- as made your own...very well done, and i cant wait for more :)
And from one author to another... that really means a lot coming from you. Appreciate the high compliment. Next chapter is up. Enjoy! :)

sirc
10/27/2006 02:18 pm
Ch 2 - Surprises Abound         
Great chapter :d
Thanks for taking the time to review. :)

SpaceLord
07/06/2006 07:50 pm
Ch 2 - Surprises Abound         
Great start....I really think I'm going to love this.
Oh, I certainly hope so. I'll do my best to keep it up to standards. :)

Mali
07/06/2006 02:42 pm
Ch 2 - Surprises Abound         
Aww, poor Buffy. Please, please include some spuffy interaction in the next chapter!
Spuffy is coming. I promise you won't have to wait too much longer. Should have another chapter up tonight. :)

07/06/2006 07:12 am
Ch 2 - Surprises Abound         
I like this story a lot, as I am an avid LoTR fan. Nice work! It's definately original. I'm looking forward to an update!
I don't believe there is a nicer compliment than being original, so I thank you for that. Should have the next update posted tonight. Enjoy! :)

vladt
07/06/2006 05:51 am
Ch 2 - Surprises Abound         
that was fun, thanks. now, the questions and long, long answers.
Ehh, actually the answers are going to be greatly abbreviated, all things considered. I have other things I want to do with our Scoobies and too much exposition would get in the way of that. Next update should be up tonight. Enjoy! :)

07/06/2006 04:36 am
Ch 2 - Surprises Abound         
Yeah! More of the story! I'm looking forward to more of this one and all of your other stories as well. =)
Thank you very much for including all my stories there. I've got the next chapter of The Kindred Series Book Two almost finished. And I'm still working on the next section of The Path Less Traveled, but I've really struggled with the words in this section. Not sure why, but a view will flow and then it just dries up and I don't know what to do with my people, so I have to set them aside and work on another story. Hopefully I'll get over that hurdle soon. I should have the next chapter of The Circle Unbroken posted tonight. Enjoy! :)

07/06/2006 04:24 am
Ch 2 - Surprises Abound         
“Are you sure you’re not Robin Hood?
lmao
great fic. i have read so many anti xander fics(which don't get me wrong i do love) that i had forgot how much i loved xander the first couple of seasons. great to read a fic where i can like xander again. great work. am waiting not so patiently for more :)
Glad you're liking this one. I almost didn't post it, to be honest. Wasn't sure that there would be any interest in a crossover fic with LoTR, but the feedback has been tremendous. Glad you like Xander here - I do too! Next chapter should be posted tonight. Enjoy! :)

07/06/2006 12:34 am
Ch 2 - Surprises Abound         
wow...slayer xander, huh? very intriguing...another excellent chapther :)
Thank you, thank you, thank you very much. I wasn't planning on doing that to Xander originally, but it happened and it worked, so here we are. Hopefully the growth they both experience from this will come across well in the story. Appreciate the review. Should have another update posted tonight. :)

sirc
10/27/2006 02:04 pm
Ch 1 - From Here to There         
I think I'm oging to like this. Well done :D
Thank you! I hope you continue to enjoy. :)

vladt
07/06/2006 05:39 am
Ch 1 - From Here to There         
very good beginning to a long and invovle tale, i hope. thanks for the fine read.
And thank you for the fine review. More updates soon. Enjoy! :)

07/05/2006 09:27 pm
Ch 1 - From Here to There         
wow love the start. really hope you continue this one. i have never really got into lotr fics but this one looks great so far.
Thank you, thank you. Appreciate the generous review. Hope I don't let you down along the way. Next chapter out soon. :)

07/05/2006 02:35 pm
Ch 1 - From Here to There         
this is a fascinating idea...i'm a huge LOTR fan as well as a buffy fan so this should be great!!! love the idea of spike becoming this great renowned warrior in middle earth...love howw all the scoobies are as accepting as they should have been all along...great start and cant wait for more :)
I've been re-reading the Hobbit and the LoTR trilogy every year since I was 12, so when I got this idea, I had to combine two of my favorite venues. Thanks for the compliment and next chapter will be out soon. :)

dihcar
07/05/2006 11:09 am
Ch 1 - From Here to There         
Very nice start, i like your strong written SPike. And glad to see some hope of a frienship between Spike and the scoobies, mainly xander, since his hatred for Spike was the most vocal.

seeya
Thank you for the great review. I always hated the bigotry in the Scoobies - had to get rid of that right up front! :)

Tonia
07/05/2006 10:07 am
Ch 1 - From Here to There         
Update! Update! Update!
I have a huge weakness for well done crossovers. =)
Is less than 24 hours fast enough for an update? Hope so, 'cause the rest will likely not be as quick to post. But hopefully you'll continue to view this as a 'well-done' crossover. Thanks for the kind review. :)